What is the most promising AR/MR optical see-through display core tech? Waveguide, Birdbath or Off-a

Generally speaking, there are three competing optical see-through AR/MR Display Core Tech, namely, Waveguide, Birdbath, Off-axis Reflector, competing to be the king of next generation of big-screen display core tech, offering consumers as Monitor screen, LCD TV, Laser TV and Movie Theater screen replacement.

1) Waveguide optical architect. It has its pros but comes with the following limitations:

  • FOV is not large enough (between 30° and 52° in a diagonal direction),

  • Its light efficiency is typically quite low, <2%

  • System resolution (MTF of the whole system) is typically quite low due to diffraction optical limitations,

  • Inaccurate color, hard to show single color uniform background well, i.e., a white background would show as a messy colorful background,

  • Very expensive (i.e., HoloLens is well over $3000, MagicLeap one is at $2295), not really for consumer uses.

See waveguide Display Tech history and its state of art as of 2019:

Fig 1. Waveguide AR Display history and its state of art as of 2019. MagicLeap One is the latest Art

2) Birdbath optical architect. Birdbath has a very long and rich history, while it has its pros, it comes with the following limitations:

  • It has a fundamental privacy leaking issue, as others can see the display content from outside, from all directions,

  • Its light efficiency is quite low, <12.5%

  • FOV is quite similar to waveguide technology, not large enough (between 40° and 55° in a diagonal direction),

  • The optics are too close to the user’s eye area. The system typically put weight (i.e., >85g or even >100g) on the load-sensitive-human-nose (i.e., typical prescription eye-glasses weight is <30g for the nose to support), uncomfortable to use,

  • Also due to the optics is too close to the user’s eye area, the heat generating display unit together with the heating generating driving electronics are touching the user’s sensitive skin area near the eye, hot as burning. For these reasons, Birdbath architect is typically for short period user cases, not suitable for long period consumer user cases like movie watching or gaming, etc.,

  • It does not fit daily myopia glasses thus not convenient for many,

  • Its eyebox is quite small, quite easy to loss the image.

See Birdbath Display Tech history and its state of art as of 2019:

Fig 2. Birdbath AR optics history and its state of art as of 2019. Nreal Light is the latest art

3) Off-axis Reflector optical architect. Historically, Off-axis Reflector was used in the Military thanks to its ultra-wide field of view (FOV) nature, i.e., Off-axis Reflector was used in pilot training program during World War 2, and were used on the F35 joint fighter information helmet, where the size and cost was not a big problem for the pilot. For example, the F35 joint fighter AR helmet was over 3 lbs, and cost about $400,000 each. To make it work, each pilot’s head needs to be individually scanned! (No problem as an air-force device)

At around 2014 - 2016 period, SmokeVR HMD

and MetaVision (AR Headset Maker Meta Furloughs After Chinese Lead Backs Out of New Investment) tried to transfer the military technology into the consumer space, by shrinking the form-factor and cost down. However, the Off-axis Reflector at the time suffered a set of problems:

  • The relatively low image quality (system MTF) as Off-axis systems tend to have large image distortion and the image quality drops dramatically as the system goes “off-axis”. To overcome the limitations, an image formation method called “Free-Form Reflector” was necessary, but the Free-Form Reflector technique was so new and uncommon to most experts in the field (other than a few lucky folks who by chance spent many years on related in-depth research in World Class Optical Institute, and in relevant Top National Lab doing the very uncommon toroidal surface, ellipsoidal surface, KB mirrors image, etc. ), people just started exploring how to make Free-Form Reflector work. And there were simply too many unknowns on how to design/produce/test high quality non-traditional Free-Form Reflector, etc.

  • For the same reason, the image plane of the early “infant” Free-Form Reflector tend to very close to the mirror itself, i.e., forming an image at about 1-foot to 1.5-foot from the Mirror itself. When the users of the HMD put the device on, they will find the image is right in front of their eye. This very close by image distance issue made the HMD hardly useful, as the users feel as if they were standing right in front of a big screen and the contents were simply way too close-by to be comfortable watched,

  • If the software renders the content to further distance (depth) anyway, the image became fuzzy too quickly, thus only large font/coarse content is viewable,

  • The above image quality issue and image distance issue, when coupled with the other factors below, basically killed the Off-axis Reflector system:

  • Even though significantly smaller than the military helmet, the end system was still too bulky from a 2016 standard,

  • Even though significantly lighter than the military helmet, the end system was still too heavy from a 2016 standard, i.e., at 570g for Metavision’s AR headset,

  • Even though significantly cheaper than the military helmet, the end system was still too expensive for consumer space, i.e., at $1495 for Metavision’s AR headset.

Due to the above constraints, Off-Axis Reflector AR architect did not attract too much attention in the industry, most experts in the field simply thought this technical path was fundamentally flawed, with low image quality, and it is way too large and heavy for any civilian application. Thus, there is little development effort in this technology direction.

But things changed in 2019, a startup in Milpitas, CA, called “iGlass USA inc” showed off their palm-sized small, 200-inch gigantic screen size, 120g feather-light XGlass with “Ultra-high-image-quality beating any waveguide systems and Birdbath systems ever in exist” at multiple professional conferences, including SID 2019 in San Jose and AWE 2019 in Santa Clara.

iGlass USA uses their actual device proved that all those previous issues associated with the Off-axis Reflector AR Display Core tech can be solved through years of dedicated research and development.

Fig 3. iGlass is palm-sized small, 120g ultra-light, comes with 200-inch gigantic semi-immersive screen size. With ultra-high image quality, currently at 4K clarity, will expand to 6K and 8K soon. It fits daily myopia glasses well. Zero pressure on nose and face, very comfortable to wear

iGlass also let 1.3 million people eye witnessed how high image quality and how small and light the Off-axis Reflector AR display tech is cable of achieving. Iglass USA is so confident about this technique’s potential, it even claimed that their upcoming iGlass Two will have another 35% higher image sharpness (system MTF) than their already very sharp UHD quality XGlass demonstrated.

Fig 4. Lenovo smart phone business group president Dr. Chang Cheng is really impressed by iGlass’ Ultra-sharp-image-quality, in his Beijing Office

Hisense Chairman Mr. Zhou Houjian is really impressed by iGlass Ultra-sharp-and-vivid-image-quality, in Hisense Qingdao Headquarter

Fig 5. Hisense Chairman Mr. Zhou Houjian is really impressed by iGlass Ultra-sharp-and-vivid-image-quality, in Hisense Qingdao Headquarter

iGlass USA boasts its ultra-high-image-quality near-eye-display technology IS the next generation of Big Screen display core tech, offering a significant upgrade from the current LCD screen, Laser projection screen and Theater screen, with benefits of being small, light-weight, portable and private, with 2D/3D dual mode and bigger screen size at much lower consumer price.

See Off-axis Reflector AR optics history and its state of art as of 2019:

Fig 6. Off-axis Reflector AR optics history and its state of art as of 2019. iGlass is the latest art

Technology always leaps forward, and the art advances. Now the AR optical see-through display core tech competition race just got hotter, which is good news for ordinary consumers, who deserve better, more affordable next generation devices to improve their quality of life: